Plans to adopt legally binding rules on autonomous weapons have divided countries. Governments meeting in Geneva on Monday, November 16, are discussing proposals on military systems that can select and strike targets without human oversight. The United States and Russia oppose such restrictions, AnewZ reports.
Most of the 128 countries party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) support binding limits. Major military powers, including the United States, Russia and Israel, oppose the proposal, saying existing international humanitarian law provides sufficient safeguards.
Geneva discusses launching negotiations
A review conference of the CCW, hosted by the UN, is considering whether to begin formal negotiations on limits for lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS). The conference president has proposed a two-year mandate to draft a legally binding protocol.
The United States supports a five-year process to develop non-binding recommendations. Other proposals leave open the possibility of combining binding and voluntary rules. No agreement is expected this week; delegates must decide whether formal negotiations should begin and what form they should take.
Washington says existing international humanitarian law governs the use of autonomous weapons in armed conflicts. Russia has previously opposed legally binding limits but has not publicly stated its position ahead of the Geneva meeting. A senior Western diplomat said Moscow also intended to block representatives of the European Union, which has observer status at the conference, from speaking. Israel has also rejected calls for binding limits.
The International Committee of the Red Cross disagrees that existing humanitarian law provides sufficient protection. It says specific international regulation is needed to address the risks posed by autonomous weapons. The committee has warned that the spread of these systems could intensify conflicts and make compliance with the rules of war harder to ensure, and says meaningful human control must be maintained over their use.
Risks associated with the use of autonomous weapons
Once activated, autonomous weapons can identify and strike targets independently, although the level of human involvement varies. They differ from remotely controlled weapons, in which humans make decisions about target selection. Advances in artificial intelligence have accelerated the development of autonomous drones, robots, tanks and submarines.
Partially autonomous and AI-enabled weapons have already been used in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East. This does not mean fully autonomous weapons have been deployed. Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, referred to media reports of early use of fully autonomous systems in Ukraine and said the technology was no longer a matter of the distant future.
Human rights groups have warned that autonomous weapons could make unpredictable decisions on the battlefield, leading to unlawful attacks and civilian deaths. Verity Coyle, a representative of Human Rights Watch, said decisions of life and death should not be delegated to machines. The UN, the International Committee of the Red Cross and Pope Leo XIV have also called for tighter controls.
According to rights advocates, autonomous target selection could make it harder to distinguish civilians from combatants and to identify who is responsible when an attack causes harm. At the heart of the debate is whether machines should be allowed to select and attack targets without meaningful human control.
Despite opposition from major military powers, diplomats familiar with the discussions believe an agreement is possible. Coyle said Britain, Germany and France support starting negotiations but have not committed in advance to making their outcome legally binding. Their position lies between the conference president’s proposal for a binding protocol and Washington’s preference for voluntary recommendations.
Two diplomats said negotiations would be difficult but that an agreement combining binding and voluntary measures could offer a way forward. Delegates are expected to consider competing proposals before the conference ends later this week. An agreement to begin negotiations could pave the way for international limits on autonomous weapons; failure to reach consensus could stall efforts to establish common rules.
As artificial intelligence takes on an increasingly prominent role in warfare, governments face the central challenge of agreeing on how to discuss rules governing its use.