Skip to main content

Why International Court of Justice rulings are not always enforced

Why International Court of Justice rulings are not always enforced
— Photo: AnewZ - Latest

The UN’s principal judicial organ hears legal disputes between states. Its rulings are binding on the parties, but the court has no power of its own to enforce them.

az ru

Preparing…

The summary was written by AI from this story's own text.

That did not work. Please try again a little later.

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is the United Nations’ principal judicial organ. Known as the “World Court,” it is the only international court that hears disputes between states over alleged violations of international law.

The court, based at the Peace Palace in The Hague, has 15 judges who rule on cases ranging from border disputes to allegations of genocide, AnewZ reports. Its decisions are binding and cannot be appealed, but the court has no separate mechanism to enforce its rulings. Their implementation therefore depends on the willingness of states and pressure from the international community.

The increase in cases involving wars and human rights has brought this contradiction into sharper focus.

The court’s establishment and jurisdiction

The ICJ was established under the 1945 UN Charter to provide states with a permanent forum for settling legal disputes without resorting to war and for obtaining legal advice. The court held its first sitting on April 18, 1946. A study published in the Georgetown Journal of International Law described the court as “one of the main alternatives to the use of force.”

The ICJ and the International Criminal Court, which is also based in The Hague, have different functions. The ICJ resolves disputes between states, while the International Criminal Court tries individuals for crimes such as war crimes and genocide. The ICJ cannot find an individual guilty; it rules only on whether a state has violated international law.

The ICJ’s 15 judges are elected for nine-year terms. According to a study by the Library of Parliament of Canada, no two judges may be from the same country. Candidates must win an absolute majority in separate votes in the UN General Assembly and Security Council. The bench is intended to represent the world’s major legal systems. If no judge is a national of a country involved in a case, that country may appoint a temporary “ad hoc” judge for that case.

The same study criticizes the fact that the five permanent members of the Security Council are almost always represented by a judge on the court.

Only states may be parties to a dispute. Although all 193 UN member states can bring cases before the court, the states concerned must consent to its jurisdiction for a case to be heard. “The court obtains jurisdiction on the basis of the parties’ consent,” Tino Cuellar and Oona Hathaway of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace say.

Consent can be given in three ways: two states may agree to refer a specific dispute to the court; more than 300 international treaties, including the Genocide Convention, may provide for disputes to be brought before the ICJ; or states may declare in advance that they recognize the court’s jurisdiction. Seventy-five countries have made such a declaration.

The case involving Myanmar broadened the scope of the treaty mechanism. In a preliminary ruling in 2019, the court held that any party to a treaty protecting common obligations, such as the Genocide Convention, could bring a case, even if it had not been directly harmed. Cuellar and Hathaway link this principle to South Africa’s subsequent case against Israel.

UN bodies such as the General Assembly can also ask the court for advisory opinions on legal questions. Although these opinions are not binding, they often carry significant authority.

The court’s cases and enforcement of its rulings

The ICJ has heard cases involving land and maritime borders, hostage-taking and genocide. According to the Library of Parliament of Canada, 201 cases were entered on the court’s docket between 1947 and September 2025. About a third of the current cases involve human rights claims.

South Africa accused Israel in 2023 of committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. The court issued provisional measures, but hearings on the merits are not expected before the end of 2029. Israel rejects the allegation and says it respects international law.

In March 2022, weeks after Russia launched its full-scale invasion, the ICJ called on Moscow to “immediately suspend military operations.” The court has yet to issue a final judgment in Ukraine’s case against Russia.

The Gambia filed a case against Myanmar in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention. Human Rights Watch described it as the first case in which a country with no direct connection to the alleged crimes used its membership in the convention to bring a case before the ICJ.

The judges ruled by nine votes to six that Myanmar’s security forces and other state bodies had committed genocide during the military’s “clearance operations” in 2016 and 2017. The court said the “only reasonable conclusion” from the evidence was that Myanmar intended to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population. It also found that Myanmar had failed to meet its obligations to prevent and punish genocide.

According to Human Rights Watch, Myanmar must end ongoing violations, guarantee they will not recur and compensate Rohingya victims. Compensation should help ensure safe and voluntary return and reunite displaced families.

ICJ rulings are binding on the states involved in a dispute and cannot be appealed. However, the court has no police force or military. Under Article 94 of the UN Charter, if a state fails to comply with a ruling, the other party may turn to the Security Council. The Georgetown study notes that the council has never taken such action and is unlikely to do so. Carnegie Endowment researchers point out that any of the five permanent members can veto enforcement of a ruling.

One of the best-known examples of open defiance of a ruling is the case between Nicaragua and the United States in the 1980s. Washington refused to comply with the 1986 judgment and vetoed Nicaragua’s draft resolutions in the Security Council.

According to the Library of Parliament of Canada, rulings have been followed in “the vast majority of cases.” The authors of the Georgetown study also assess overall compliance as high, but warn that mounting pressure over enforcement threatens the court’s legitimacy. “It is difficult for a tribunal to preserve its legitimacy when its decisions are routinely disregarded,” Cuellar and Hathaway write.

The ruling on Myanmar creates binding obligations for the country, but implementation will depend largely on political pressure. Human Rights Watch has said that the Security Council has never used its authority to enforce ICJ rulings, while the General Assembly can call on states to comply with them.

“Myanmar must immediately comply with the World Court’s ruling and end its repression of the Rohingya,” said Maria Elena Vignoli, senior legal adviser for international justice at Human Rights Watch.

OMM Bot · Shall I show you today’s 5 most read stories?

Author

Editorial board

All their articles ›
Loading next story…