The African National Congress (ANC), which has dominated South African politics for more than three decades, is racing to secure power-sharing agreements in cities after a sharp loss of support in this month’s local elections, according to the BBC.
The ANC had its worst result since taking power in 1994, when South Africa ended apartheid and became a democracy. It won a majority in only one of the country’s nine provinces, Limpopo, down from six in the previous elections. It also received the most votes in just two of the country’s eight cities, compared with six in 2021.
The party won 31% of the national vote, down from 46% in the previous local election, but still received more votes than any other party. Parties have until 27 November to negotiate and form local governments.
At national level, the ANC shares power with its long-time rival, the Democratic Alliance (DA). There has been no official announcement, but ANC officials appear reluctant to reproduce that arrangement in local government.
DA leads in Gauteng cities
In Gauteng, the country’s economic powerhouse, the DA won the most votes in Johannesburg, Pretoria and the province’s other main region, Ekurhuleni. The party received 25% nationally, up from 22% five years ago.
The DA retained its majority in Cape Town, its political stronghold, and won the most votes in Nelson Mandela Bay, where Gqeberha, formerly known as Port Elizabeth, is located. The DA was the only party to secure an overall majority in a city.
The left-leaning uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party, led by former President Jacob Zuma, came third nationally with 10% of the vote. That repeated its third-place result in the 2024 national election, after which it became the official opposition when the DA joined the coalition government.
The MK Party was the largest party in KwaZulu-Natal, which includes the port city of Durban, winning 34% of the vote. It will need to agree a coalition with other parties to govern there.
ANC courts smaller parties as coalition tensions persist
The ANC and DA have had a strained relationship since joining a coalition with eight other parties in 2024. They agreed to share power after the ANC lost its parliamentary majority for the first time since apartheid ended, forming what is known as the Government of National Unity (GNU).
The parties have continued to disagree on major issues, and both have threatened to end the arrangement. Before the local elections, analysts had predicted they might cooperate at municipal level, as they do nationally.
Instead, the ANC appears to have turned down that option. South African broadcaster SABC reported that most of the party’s senior leaders regard an agreement with the DA as a last resort. The ANC has been seeking support from smaller parties to form city councils.
In Gauteng, reports point to a possible arrangement between the ANC and ActionSA, an anti-immigration party that won 17% in the province and emerged as the third-largest party there. That result could make it a kingmaker. The DA has also sought agreements with smaller parties and the ANC, but appears likely to move to the opposition benches in Gauteng.
ActionSA is unlikely to work with the DA because the parties cannot agree on mayoral candidates in Johannesburg and Pretoria.
It is too early to know whether the local election result signals a breakdown in the ANC-DA relationship nationally. Neither party has publicly addressed the future of their national arrangement during the coalition talks, but the ANC’s reluctance to work with the DA in major cities points to continuing tensions.
The GNU has remained in place since its formation in 2024. However, some ANC members have objected to what they see as the DA acting both as a coalition partner and an opposition party, and have called for the arrangement to end.
An ANC insider told the Daily Maverick on Sunday that a nationwide agreement to work with the DA at municipal level “was overwhelmingly rejected” at a party meeting.
Political analyst Andre Duvenhage told the BBC that “a lot of asymmetrical coalitions” could emerge, with parties cooperating in some areas and opposing one another elsewhere. Some experts say the DA may need to reconsider its place in the national coalition.
Analyst Sandile Swana said any party that left the GNU because it failed to secure local agreements would be “shooting yourself in the foot”.
Coalitions face questions over service delivery
Voters want local governments to improve services. The ANC’s decline has been linked mainly to high levels of corruption and reduced public confidence in its ability to provide electricity, water and rubbish collection.
Some credit the DA’s increased support to its record of competent management in municipalities it controls. Others accuse the party of neglecting poorer areas and townships.
Coalition governments’ record over the past decade has done little to reassure voters that services will improve. Half of South Africa’s cities have been governed through power-sharing agreements since 2016, arrangements often regarded as unstable and chaotic. When agreements collapse and new ones are formed, basic services have frequently been affected.
The issue has been especially visible in Gauteng, where governance in all three cities has faced scrutiny in recent years, partly because of unstable administrations.
Experts say that even after new arrangements take effect, resolving problems in many municipalities will take longer than a five-year term, particularly in Johannesburg, South Africa’s largest city.
“I think if we are really turning the ship around, we are talking about a 10-year period,” Duvenhage said.
Swana also said it would take a decade to “cleanse and purify” local councils and “reinstate them as proper municipalities”.