A federal court in Boston ruled that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) likely acted unlawfully by narrowing a decades-old training program used by foreign students. More than 140,000 international students participate in the program.
U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick, based in Boston, issued an order suspending two directives DHS sent to universities in August, AnewZ reported.
Higher education groups said the directives abruptly disrupted training opportunities for international students nationwide. The ruling allows international students enrolled at U.S. universities to take part in internships and other practical training while the legal dispute continues.
DHS declined to comment.
The case concerns curricular practical training, or CPT, which allows students studying on visas to take part in internships and other training related to their field of study.
Four organizations that filed suit last month said foreign students had been allowed for more than 35 years to take part in training approved by their educational institutions. The training had to be directly related to a student’s field of study and an integral part of an established curriculum.
The plaintiffs include the Association of American Universities and the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration. The organizations said the government had long interpreted the criterion to cover training that either earns academic credit or is required to obtain a degree.
In August, however, DHS told universities that training would qualify only if it was mandatory for all students enrolled in the relevant degree program. Training taken optionally for academic credit would no longer meet the criterion. The department said it had seen an increase in CPT approvals that it believed violated program rules and would step up oversight.
Judge says directives differed from previous position
Kobick said the directives were likely “arbitrary and capricious” under the Administrative Procedure Act, which governs how federal agencies make rules. In the judge’s view, DHS had not acknowledged that it was substantially changing its longstanding interpretation of the program.
“Whether right or wrong, this new interpretation is inconsistent with the government’s prior position,” wrote Kobick, who was appointed by former President and Democrat Joe Biden.
According to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, 140,775 student visa holders were authorized to participate in CPT in 2024. That year, Amazon and Tesla were the two companies that hired the most CPT students.
The ruling is another victory for opponents of the Trump administration’s efforts to restrict student visa holders as part of its hard-line immigration policies. On Monday, another federal judge in Boston struck down a new rule that would have limited how long foreign students could remain in the United States without applying for an extension.