Skip to main content

Ukraine says Russia struck rescue operation after attack killed at least 72

Ukraine says Russia struck rescue operation after attack killed at least 72
— Photo: BBC World

Ukrainian officials say Russian forces carried out repeated strikes during rescue work after an attack on a humanitarian aid centre in Komyshuvakha on 2 November. The death toll has risen to at least 72, according to Ukraine’s State Emergency Service.

ru

Preparing…

The summary was written by AI from this story's own text.

That did not work. Please try again a little later.

Ukrainian officials have accused Russia of targeting rescue and recovery teams after an attack that killed at least 72 people in the village of Komyshuvakha, near the front line. The allegations were reported by BBC Verify.

Ukraine says two strikes hit a humanitarian aid centre on 2 November, including a 3,000kg (6,600lb) aerial bomb that struck a shelter where residents had taken cover. Images verified by BBC Verify show damage to emergency vehicles and excavation equipment at the site.

The State Emergency Service of Ukraine (DSNS) told BBC Verify that Russian strikes took place during rescue operations. Three police officers, four workers and two rescue dogs were injured, while five vehicles were damaged.

“Due to the threat of repeated shelling, emergency workers are constantly forced to periodically suspend work and retreat to a safe place,” the DSNS said.

The agency said the death toll had reached at least 72, making the incident one of the deadliest single events since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.

Warnings of a second strike

Oleksiy, an intelligence officer with Ukraine’s SBU security service investigating the incident, said rescue vehicles were “clearly marked” and accused Russia of “deliberately destroying humanitarian equipment”. He asked to be identified only by his first name.

Oleksiy also said the village’s infrastructure and the people who remain there are being systematically targeted by drones and bombs. He accused Russian forces of “outright terror against civilians, against peaceful residents” intended to make life near the front line impossible.

BBC Verify confirmed videos shared by Ukrainian police showing rescue workers at the scene shouting “drone, drone” and running for cover on the day after the attack. A group of people can also be seen treating a victim.

Oleksiy said bodies had yet to be recovered from the rubble. “The enemy knows perfectly well that what is being carried out there is essentially a humanitarian operation to search for the dead,” he said.

BBC Verify said it had asked Russia’s Ministry of Defence for comment specifically about the attacks in Komyshuvakha but had received no response. A general statement issued by the ministry on 2 November said it had targeted energy and transport infrastructure used by the Ukrainian military across the country.

Komyshuvakha has no military or industrial facilities, but lies near a key route used for Ukrainian troop movements, supplies and evacuations. The village had also reportedly been struck by Russian forces on 28 October.

Local people went to the shelter area on 2 November after a local Telegram group said aid would be distributed from 10:00 to 12:00 local time (08:00 to 10:00 GMT). Ukrainian authorities said an initial strike at 09:45 hit buildings above ground and killed a woman.

Edited body-camera footage released by Ukrainian police and analysed by BBC Verify shows people trying to free a casualty from rubble before saying she had died. Warnings of a possible second strike can be heard on police radios, growing more urgent until people are told to run to the underground shelter.

The footage, recorded about an hour after the first attack, then shows people waiting silently in a shelter. A large explosion is heard before the video goes dark.

Later footage shows bodies being recovered from a large crater directly above the shelter, with twisted iron and rubble from the structure below visible beneath the surface.

Funerals have been held almost daily for those killed, including local people involved in distributing aid, people who had gone to collect it and soldiers who, according to officials, arrived to assist with rescue efforts.

Experts assess the bomb damage

Trevor Ball, a bomb disposal expert at intelligence firm Armament Research Services, said the crater shown in footage was consistent with the damage and depth caused by a FAB-3000, a Russian 3,000kg bomb capable of destroying underground structures.

Chris Proops, a former UK National Crime Agency investigator, said the scale of the damage matched the size of a FAB-3000.

Ball and Proops also confirmed that verified photographs of munition fragments obtained by BBC Verify from Ukrainian authorities showed part of a guidance kit compatible with a FAB-3000. The kit improves the weapon’s accuracy and allows it to be fired from farther away from its target.

International law experts told BBC Verify that Russia would have committed a war crime if it knowingly attacked rescue workers.

Ben Saul, a professor of international law at the University of Sydney, said the incident “appears to be either a deliberate attack on civilians or civilian objects — a war crime — or an indiscriminate attack — also a war crime”.

Samuel Moyn, a professor at Yale University, said “directly targeting rescuers or their equipment is a gross violation of international humanitarian law”. He added that precautions must be taken to ensure strikes target combatants rather than others.

OMM Bot · Shall I show you today’s 5 most read stories?

Author

Editorial board

All their articles ›
Loading next story…