Countries failed to reach a major new deal to tackle climate change at the UN COP31 talks in Turkey, after divisions over fossil fuels and financial support widened, according to the BBC.
Negotiations were scheduled to end on Friday but continued into Sunday as delegates sought common ground, making COP31 the longest UN climate conference in history.
The final deal was unacceptable to the European Union, Pacific island nations and others because it did not directly mention fossil fuels, the main cause of global warming. Many poorer countries also objected that it contained no clear financial commitments from richer nations to help them adapt to rising temperatures.
The last time a COP’s main political agreement collapsed was in 2009 in Copenhagen. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, speaking at his final COP before stepping down, said he was “deeply disappointed”.
Guterres criticised what he called “powerful fossil fuel interests”, accusing them of taking “a page from Big Tobacco’s playbook: distorting the science, delaying policy, blocking action, and piling up huge profits while people everywhere pay the price”.
After two weeks of negotiations, delegates were presented with a new draft deal in the early hours of Sunday in an effort to break the deadlock. But the words “fossil fuels” did not appear in the text. Its only indirect reference to coal, oil and gas was a mention of the agreement reached at COP28 in 2023, when countries agreed to “transition away” from fossil fuels in energy systems.
The EU’s representative, Irish Minister Darragh O’Brien, said the bloc “strongly” objected, adding that the decisions “go nowhere near the level of ambition needed to tackle climate change”.
“It is unconscionable that we would have a climate pact that makes no mention of fossil fuels,” O’Brien said.
Panama, the Marshall Islands and other countries also criticised the deal, saying it did not do enough to address the pace of climate change.
An initial draft on Monday referred to “fossil fuel” or “fossil fuels” six times, but oil-producing nations rejected that wording. Saudi Arabia’s delegate, Mohammad Ayoub, said Arab countries had “continued to engage in good faith” and argued they were responsible for only a small share of historical greenhouse gas emissions.
Russia warned against turning coal, oil and gas into “slogans” and argued that moving away from fossil fuels too quickly would lead to “fuel poverty”.
Climate finance for poorer countries to adapt to impacts such as more intense heatwaves and severe droughts was another major point of disagreement. At COP30 in Brazil last year, countries agreed to triple finance for that purpose.
The COP31 deal contained neither concrete figures nor a baseline for measuring the pledge, raising concerns that richer nations would have too much room to manoeuvre.
“Rich nations and polluting governments cannot keep arriving empty-handed,” said Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa, an African climate and energy think tank.
UK Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh called the failure to reach a political agreement “immensely disappointing”. She said it strengthened the UK’s resolve to work with partners around the world on progress made in Antalya to tackle the climate crisis, adding that the UK’s commitment was “unwavering”.
Talks take place amid rising climate risks
Although the talks were hosted in Antalya, Turkey, Australia led the official negotiations, creating what some observers described as a chaotic dynamic.
Chris Bowen, an Australian government minister and COP31 president of negotiations, said the discussions involved “unbridgeable red lines”. He cited “the most complicated and fraught geopolitical environment in living memory” and said climate impacts were worsening, raising the stakes.
The year 2026 could become the hottest on record and has brought extreme weather and natural hazards to many parts of the world, from summer heat and drought in Europe to flash flooding in Nepal.
COP31 was the first annual UN conference to formally discuss the prospect of missing one of the key international targets for limiting climate change. At the 2015 Paris talks, nearly 200 countries agreed to try to limit global warming to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels in the late 1800s, with the aim of avoiding some of climate change’s worst effects.
The UN says the Paris agreement has driven “near-universal” climate action. In the early 2010s, warming of 4C or more by the end of the century was considered a serious possibility. Based on current government policies, the world is now likely to limit warming to about 2.8C by 2100, the UN says.
However, action has not been fast enough to meet the Paris target, and the world is likely to “overshoot” 1.5C of long-term warming in the next few years. Many countries say they remain committed to eventually bringing warming back down to 1.5C, but doing so would require a major expansion of technologies to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, which do not yet exist at scale.
Although the main deal fell through, some agreements were reached, including progress on a “just transition mechanism”, a framework to support workers and communities as economies move towards clean energy.
The COP31 president also said that more than 80 countries backed Turkey’s target of increasing the share of global energy use met by electricity to 35% by 2035.
Following the talks, some questioned whether the UN climate process, which relies on consensus, could succeed in a geopolitically divided world.
UN climate chief Simon Stiell said he would seek advice on possible reforms to the process. The next conference, COP32, is scheduled for November 2027 in Ethiopia.
“The consensus process has worked to get us where we are,” Stiell told the BBC. “It got us through Paris... so it can work.” He acknowledged that it “fell short” at COP31.
The UN climate process had “suffered setback before and come back stronger”, Stiell told delegates. “It must do so again.”